 |
| The Doctor daydreams about being a romantic hero and saving the ship. |
Original Air Date: Oct. 13, 1999. Written by: Joe Menosky. Story by: Bill Vallely. Directed by: John Bruno.
THE PLOT:
The Doctor is daydreaming.
He's suffered twin slights. First, he's snubbed for an Away Mission; then Janeway denies his proposal to make him an "Emergency Command Hologram" with authorization to take command should the crew be incapacited. So he retreats into daydreams in which he does get put in charge, each time saving the ship from an overwhelming threat... and receiving full appreciation from the ship's female officers.
All of this is harmless, even ordinary. But it's happening while Voyager is being observed by an alien ship. Observer Phlox (Jay M. Leggett) has received approval from the Hierarchy to interface with Voyager in order to gather intelligence. He ends up connecting with the Doctor, observing his fantasies - which convinces Phlox and the others that the Doctor's daydreams are reality!
The Hierarchy authorizes an attack. When Voyager realizes what is happening, they're left to scramble to recreate the Doctor's daydreams in order to save the ship - for real!
CHARACTERS:
Capt. Janeway: Though she declines the Doctor's proposal, she tries to be compassionate, telling the rest of the command staff to be more respectful of his feelings. When the Doctor's fantasies are made viewable in the holodeck, Janeway is hesitant about intruding on his privacy. Around all the outlandish fantasies about saving the ship, she catches a glimpse of him talking about living up to his full potential. This moves her, and there's a marked difference in her interactions with him afterward.
The Doctor: The episode's a showcase for Robert Picardo's comedic abilities. It opens with him singing opera, only to improvise lyrics when Fantasy Tuvok begins going through pon'farr. His "save the ship" fantasies see him channeling square jawed action heroes. When he's tasked with playing that role for real, however, he's anxious and nervous. Picardo hits every note perfectly, elevating an already good script.
Seven of Nine: Though the Doctor's imagination finds time to muse about both Torres and Janeway, Seven is the principle object of his fantasy affections. This is actually a nice bit of continuity with Someone to Watch Over Me, in which he ultimately kept his attraction to Seven unspoken. The holodeck allows Seven to see his attraction directly. She doesn't respond with anger, instead being mostly bemused and a bit sarcastic - particularly when she delivers her final line of the episode.
Phlox: The main alien character, whose situation parallels the Doctor's. Like the Doctor, he feels disrespected... though given his sneering and officious Overlooker, Phlox has a better case for the disrespect being genuine. Like the Doctor, he wants to prove his abilities, which leads to him monitoring the Doctor and Voyager. He laments that his species' thinking is "confined," and he admires the Doctor for being able to conceive of other possibilities.
THOUGHTS:
Tinker Tenor Doctor Spy is Voyager's "Walter Mitty" episode, with the Doctor fantasizing heroic and romantic situations for himself. It would be a fun trifle even if that was all there was to this. The scenarios are genuinely amusing, and Picardo performs with comic gusto. But if there was nothing more to it, then I suspect it would start to feel a bit stretched by the end.
Thankfully, the final script is by Joe Menosky, one of 1990's Trek's best writers for both theme and characterization. Menosky hits the comic beats that are expected from the concept, but he also captures the characters. Janeway, the Doctor, and Seven get the bulk of the material, but there are well-scripted moments for everyone, making this a rare Voyager to make good use of the full ensemble.
Chakotay plays devil's advocate when Janeway considers the Doctor's proposal, pointing out how crucial his primary responsibilities are and wondering how comfortable she would be putting a computer in command. Torres is slightly impatient in her interactions with the Doctor, but she shows concern when his daydreams take over and put him in danger. Tom opines that the Doctor's manner creates many of the problems he's complaining about. Neelix and Harry both speak up for the value of daydreams, something that Janeway ultimately echoes. Tom and Harry are greatly amused when they observe the Doctor's fantasies. Everyone gets at least something to do.
There's also a theme that emerges, seen with both the Doctor and Phlox, about how it can be unhealthy to box someone into a confined set of duties indefinitely. Variations are voiced throughout the second half, but the Doctor says it best:
"All I ever wanted was to live up to my full potential, to hone all my skills, expand my abilities, to help the people I love."
Janeway, the good commander (in this episode at least), is moved to immediately begin searching for reasonable ways to let the Doctor expand his responsibilities. Phlox's Overlooker, the bad commander, just wants his people to know and stay in their place, declaring anything that deviates from the norm to be an "unacceptable risk."
The episode encourages us to identify with Phlox as much as the Doctor, and their converging threads advance the theme alongside the comedy. This lends just enough substance to make a superficially silly bit of fluff into something more.
OVERALL:
Tinker Tenor Doctor Spy is a fine episode: Funny, well-structured, and well-paced. With strong character work, good thematic unity, and an excellent performance by Robert Picardo, this is a highly enjoyable outing.
Overall Rating: 9/10.
Previous Episode: Barge of the Dead
Next Episode: Alice
Review Index
To receive new review updates, follow me:
On Twitter:
On Threads:
No comments:
Post a Comment