Showing posts with label Malon. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Malon. Show all posts

Friday, March 17, 2023

5-21. Juggernaut.

Malon Controller Fesek (Ron Canada) and his crewman,
Pelk (Lee Arenberg), leave a mess for Voyager to clean up...

Original Air Date: Apr. 26, 1999.  Written by: Bryan Fuller, Nick Sagan, Kenneth Biller. Directed by: Allan Kroeker.


THE PLOT

An automated distress call leads Voyager to a ruined Malon freighter. They rescue Controller Fesek (Ron Canada), the Malon captain, and bride officer Pelk (Lee Arenberg) from nearby escape pods, only to learn that the freighter is mere hours from exploding and destroying everything within three light years. Though Fesek urges Janeway to flee to safety, she insists on sending a team onto the Malon ship to stop the explosion.

The two Malon survivors beam over with Chakotay, Torres, and Neelix. They must vent the deadly radiation on each deck in order to reach the control room to stop the explosion. But they may not be alone, as one of the Malon fears that a mythical and malevolent beast known as a Vihaar may lurk within the radiation, waiting to strike at the intruders...


CHARACTERS

Capt. Janeway: Her patience for the Malon seems to be pretty much exhausted by this point. When Fesek insists that he will not risk his life returning to the irradiated, self-destructing ship, Janeway flatly tells him that he can either assist or be returned to his escape pod. Her disdain for the Malon, well-earned in previous encounters, makes her absolute scorn of Fesek palpable, and he wisely does not try to call her bluff. Though she hopes for the Away Team's success, she is realistic enough about their dangerous and difficult mission to prepare a "Plan B."

Chakotay: He does a good job as commander of the Away Team, keeping the party moving but refusing to compromise safety. When one of the Malon claims to have seen a creature in the waste, Chakotay decrees that no member of the team will work alone from that point. When Torres becomes infected with radiation, Chakotay does not allow her to refuse immediate treatment.

Torres: This is a B'Elanna-centric episode - one which insists that her anger issues have her perpetually on the edge of violent outbursts. The script is credited to no less than three writers, none of whom apparently recall that she has been able to control her emotions and deal with crises even when kidnapped by robots or stalked by a psychotic hologram. In short, Juggernaut delivers my least favorite form of "character development": reducing B'Elanna to her single, worst trait so that we can pretend that it's "progress" when she returns to her normal self.

Neelix: Since I'm spending most of this review talking about things that don't work, I'll acknowledge one thing that works very well: The use of Neelix. It's entirely consistent with what we know of his background that he's worked with similar waste disposal systems. This allows him to be a genuine asset rather than the usual buffoonish comic relief. Even his one pure comedy scene, in which he cooks up a foul-tasting brew to protect himself from radiation poisoning, is used to reinforce both his experience in this type of situation and the seriousness of it, as he recalls how this wretched recipe kept himself and his shipmates alive.


MY ORIGINAL POINT OF ABANDONMENT:

This was the last episode of Voyager that I watched in full before stopping the series back in 2017. I emphasize that it did not, on its own, make me stop viewing/reviewing Voyager.  Longtime visitors to this site likely noticed that I posted zero reviews for a 2 - 3 year period, mostly due to a combination of schedule and general burnout. If it hadn't been this episode that stalled my Voyager run, it would have been another one not far down the road.

That said, I have one and only one memory of my first viewing: Sitting down to write this review after the episode. I brought up my template and... proceeded to stare at the screen for several minutes. I genuinely could not think of even one interesting thing to say. Juggernaut is not hilariously dreadful in the manner of Favorite Son, The Fight, or The Disease. It just sort of... occupies space for 45 minutes and then ends.


THOUGHTS

Revisiting this episode now, without the burnout that plagued me at the time, I can see that Juggernaut is at least trying to take the previously one-note Malon and turn them into a society of actual individuals. In earlier episodes, they have simply been polluters and nothing more. This episode attempts to add some depth. It does not make them interesting on its own - but the cues of this script could potentially be used to create something worthwhile later.

Given that all three of the credited writers have penned good scripts, it is disappointing how much this episode relies on Idiot Plotting. The greatest immediate source of jeopardy for the Away Team is that they are working in a heavily irradiated environment. On the mission, however, they wear absolutely no protective gear, relying solely on an inoculation. We have seen crew members use gear in other Trek shows, so it's not like such things don't exist in this universe. Similarly, the transporter obviously functions, or else the crew wouldn't be able to retrieve Chakotay or contemplate sending Tuvok to replace him. So why aren't they beaming rotating overlapping shifts throughout this mission, thus limiting any one crew member's exposure?

These issues could have at least been papered over with a few lines of dialogue. The crew could have planned on using radiation suits, only for Fesek to tell them that the work was too delicate for bulky protective gear. Janeway could have intended to rotate crew, only for the transporter to be unable to penetrate the radiation (with Chakotay's emergency beam-out working, with difficulty, because of Technobabble). This script doesn't even expend that minimal amount of effort, however. There's one Away Team because there is; there's no protective gear because there isn't; and the transporters either work or don't depending on what is convenient for a given scene.

Complications are introduced in the middle, but most of them never build to anything. Each incident is just that - a bit of activity to fill airtime during the middle of the episode. There's a villain reveal at the end; save for some added gruesomeness, this scene would be perfectly at home in a Scooby-Doo episode. The entire finale is ridiculously poor. It's meant to show "character growth" that B'Elanna attempts to speechify... never mind that the urgency of the situation would actually make her (allegedly) normal aggression a more appropriate response.


OVERALL:

After a reasonably promising start, Juggernaut quickly devolves into being simultaneously tedious and stupid. It's not the worst of Voyager; it's not even the worst of the past five episodes (a group that included both The Disease and The Fight). But just because it's not rock bottom doesn't mean it isn't bad.


Overall Rating: 2/10.

Previous Episode: Think Tank
Next Episode: Someone to Watch Over Me

Review Index

To receive new review updates, follow me:

On Twitter:

On Threads:

Sunday, September 20, 2015

5-3. Extreme Risk.

B'Elanna tries to ride out an explosion.
THE PLOT

Voyager encounters the Malon again, when a Malon ship attempts to steal a telemetry probe. Tuvok is able to do some remote Technobabble that allows the probe to escape into the atmosphere of a gas giant. Borg shielding designed by Seven allows the device to survive the atmosphere - but proves too much for the pursuing Malon ship, which is destroyed.

The next problem is retrieving the probe. Tom Paris proposes building a specialized ship, which he names the Delta Flyer, using a design of his that incorporates Borg shielding and is directly aimed at maneuvering through high pressure atmosphere. Seven, Tuvok, and Harry all respond enthusiastically, and Janeway authorizes the project.

But B'Elanna seems oddly detached from a project that should be an engineer's dream. She puts in the hours, but ducks off to the holodeck every moment she's not working. When Chakotay finds her badly injured, he and Janeway realize that she has been running high risk holodeck programs with the safeties off - and that this behavior has been going on for months!


CHARACTERS

Capt. Janeway: Values life in general enough to try to warn the first Malon ship against chasing the probe into the gas giant's atmosphere. When a second Malon ship arrives while the Delta Flyer is still under construction, she attempts to settle the dispute through communication, with it being the Malon who refuse to talk. Once she realizes B'Elanna has been running dangerous holodeck programs with safeties off for months, she tries to talk to her about this behavior. When the engineer lies and denies that she has a problem, Janeway insists that she will remain off duty and under the Doctor's supervision until further notice.

Chakotay: As Torres' friend and former commanding officer, he investigates her holodeck use. When he turns up a program that simulates the massacre of their Maquis friends by the Jem'Hadar, he pushes her into viewing it, forcing her to talk about the situation even when she doesn't want to. In real life, such a confrontation would be at most a starting point for a very long recovery. This being Voyager, Chakotay's pushing and a convenient life-or-death mission magically cure her... But the episode should still get points for actually remembering these two characters' history, and for making use of it.

Torres: This episode is basically to B'Elanna what last season's Vis a Vis was to Tom: A "character" episode that manufactures an ongoing crisis we had no previous evidence of, all so that resetting to normal at the end feels like some kind of real character development. It was a cheat then and it's a cheat now - But here, it's even more aggravating because what supposedly sparked B'Elanna's crisis could have worked, had it simply been built up to over a span of episodes prior to this. But since she's behaved normally in all previous episodes, it's unconvincing when we're told that she's been withdrawn for months. Roxann Dawson gives her usual strong performance, which helps to keep this trite drama watchable.

Tom Paris: Knows something is wrong when B'Elanna shows no interest in constructing the Delta Flyer, the exact type of collaboration the two of them have previously talked about wanting to do. When she refuses to talk to him, he focuses his attention on getting the ship finished, but his concern is clear. The part of Tom that yearns for times past shows in his insistence on putting in manual controls, based on his Captain Proton holodeck program, in addition to the Starfleet touch screens. "I am tired of tapping panels. For once, I want controls that let me actually feel the ship I'm piloting!" Still, he's not impractical - The knobs and buttons may be fully functional, but there is also a touch pad for him to use, and it's the touch pad that is his primary control method on the actual mission.


THOUGHTS

More than anything else, my problem with Extreme Risk is that it's a wasted opportunity. The idea of the massacre of the Maquis creating emotional turmoil for ex-Maquis members of the Voyager crew is a good one. It makes perfect storytelling sense, it actually makes use of close to half of the ship's crew being former Maquis, and there is potential for drama and real character development. But for that to happen, one of two things needed to be done: Work the issues of a regular into the background of several episodes leading up to this one; or, if it must be a pure standalone story, have the issues affect a non-regular member of the crew, with B'Elanna and/or Chakotay helping that person to begin a recovery and reflecting on their own feelings at the same time.

As it stands, B'Elanna has shown no evidence of emotional turmoil or withdrawal during the more than half-season since learning of the deaths of the Maquis, so her behavior comes out of nowhere. This, coupled with her getting past those issues by the episode's end, leave it just feeling like a cheat. It's just filler that pretends to be character development, and as such has no real impact.

I will give credit where it's due. Kenneth Biller's script is generic, but it is fast-paced, with both the "A" and "B" plots moving quickly. Roxann Dawson, Robert Beltran, and Robert Duncan McNeill all give good performances, and it's nice to see Dawson and McNeill get a crack at the spotlight again - Something they've rarely been allowed since Seven's arrival. It's all very trite and more than a little bit silly. The emotional plot is made up of a lot of Lifetime Movie level dialogue, while the action plot is resolved by B'Elanna becoming a poor man's MacGyver. But while it's pretty bad, it isn't boring - which puts it way above, say, last season's Unforgettable.

A below-average throwaway, made more irritating because potential was here for something better. It's good to see Tom and B'Elanna get some focus again - Now let's see them get the spotlight in a good episode.


Overall Rating: 3/10.

Previous Episode; Drone
Next Episode: In the Flesh

Search Amazon.com for Star Trek: Voyager


Review Index

To receive new review updates, follow me:

On Twitter:

On Threads:

Sunday, July 26, 2015

5-1. Night.

Janeway looks out into the void...
THE PLOT

Voyager has spent two months traveling through a void, a region of space containing no star systems for 2,500 light years - or two years of their journey. Chakotay is concerned. Crew morale is already dropping, and Capt. Janeway has secluded herself in her quarters. Every viewport shows nothing but endless blackness, tempers are fraying, and there is no relief in sight.

Until they are attacked by aliens, that is. These unnamed aliens attack the ship, draining its power. They ignore all hails, and Voyager is saved only by the intervention of Emck (Ken Magee), who introduces himself as a Malon. Emck offers Voyager a shortcut through the void - a nearby vortex, which allows direct passage to his home on the other side.

One of the unnamed aliens, captured by Seven of Nine, tells the crew that Emck is poisoning them, dumping toxic waste in their space. Emck does not deny this when confronted, and he seems unbothered by the deaths of the aliens. The Voyager crew resolves to stop him from continuing his destructive work - Even if doing so may mean the destruction of the very vortex that can get them both out of this void, and two years closer to home!


CHARACTERS

Capt. Janeway: Two months in the void has given her a long time to think about her decision to destroy the Caretaker instead of using it to bring them home. Shutting herself away in her quarters, she wallows in self-recrimination, insisting that her decision was selfish and short-sighted... Basically, voicing what many of the show's more critical fans had said. This exists largely to set up a somewhat forced, but passably effective, bit in which she attempts to sacrifice herself later in the episode, until the members of her command staff remind her just how much she is needed.

Chakotay: With Janeway in seclusion, Chakotay is left to carry much of the episode. He runs the department head meetings, deflecting questions about the captain's status by reminding the others that she has no obligation to be constantly present when there's no emergency. When alone with Janeway, he argues the reverse - That her seclusion is bad for the crew's morale. Even when she's stirred by the crisis with the aliens, he recognizes that she is in a dangerous frame of mind, and enlists Tuvok's agreement to save her from herself if the need arises.

Tuvok: He meditates in Astrometrics, drily observing to Seven of Nine that "the view from (his) quarters has been less than stellar lately." He expresses surprise at Chakotay approaching him, indicating that the two have regarded each other with mistrust and kept their distance - That's something I wish we'd actually seen in the background of earlier episodes, because it would have made sense for both characters and might been interesting! Ah, well. As Janeway's friend, he is aware of her tendency toward self-sacrifice, and agrees with Chakotay about watching her closely.

Neelix: The void is particularly difficult for him. He discovers that he suffers from "nihiliphobia - the fear of nothingness." He does his best to put on a cheerful face for the crew. He also endeavors to do his job properly, making genuinely good suggestions at the department head meeting to improve crew morale and arguing forcefully with Chakotay that this is not the time for Janeway to be unapproachable. When the alien interference results in a shipwide blackout, his phobia leaves him huddling in a corner, but he is one of the first to spot an alien on board. "I may be nihiliphobic, but my eyes work just fine!"


THOUGHTS

Night kicks off Season Five with an hour that is really two stories in one... Which is unfortunate, because one of those stories is a whole lot better than the other.

The first part is a genuinely interesting psychological and character piece. The regulars are stuck on the ship with no external stimuli. No aliens to encounter, whether friendly or hostile; no planets to visit; not even stars in the sky. Just themselves, the familiar corridors of the ship, and an endless night outside. Left in this state with only two years of the same to look forward to, they begin to fracture - Tom and B'Elanna bickering about nothing, Neelix discovering a new fear he didn't know he had, and even Tuvok rattled enough to seek out a nicer view for his meditations. It's refreshingly different than anything the show has done before, and it's entirely convincing on a character level.

So of course they have to bring some generic aliens in to blow stuff up in the second half. With a heavy-handed "message" about toxic waste grafted on for good measure.

This second half is pure formula. A two-dimensional villainous alien acts solely to profit himself, not caring that he is bringing death to two-dimensional pathetic victim aliens. Emck sneers at Janeway's offer of technological assistance to remove the need for toxic waste by observing that this would just put him out of business. His villainy fully revealed, we are left to savor in his comeuppance and nod sagely as Janeway delivers the message of the week, all in time for the convenient vortex to throw the ship out of the void so that crew and audience can pretend none of this ever happened.

If you had asked me to predict my score at any point before the aliens turned up, I'd have said this was on track to an "8." But the rote, predictable second half drained my interest in this like a vampire drinking its victim dry. It's not by any means unwatchable, even at its lowest point - But given how good the first part of the episode is, the change to generic action runaround comes as a bitterly disappointing blow.


Overall Rating: 4/10.

Previous Episode: Hope and Fear
Next Episode: Drone

Search Amazon.com for Star Trek: Voyager


Review Index

To receive new review updates, follow me:

On Twitter:

On Threads: