Showing posts with label Hirogen. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Hirogen. Show all posts

Saturday, May 30, 2015

Thoughts on Season Four.

In its fourth season, Star Trek: Voyager undergoes a major cast change, one that shifts the character dynamics considerably. But the show itself remains mostly the same beast as in its first three seasons: A series that exists mostly episode by episode, with few dramatic risks taken.

Still, for the first time in a long time, I come not to bury Voyager but to praise it. Season Four may suffer from all the same faults that have plagued the series from the beginning (a few of them actually worsen!), but the good episodes significantly outweigh the bad ones, the introduction of Seven of Nine works and works well, and the result is the most consistently enjoyable season of the show to date.


ARRIVALS: SEVEN OF NINE

This is the season that introduces Seven of Nine (Jeri Ryan), a Borg drone who unwillingly joins the Voyager crew and has to assimilate to their environment. There is a lot of potential in this concept, making it no surprise that most of the season's episodes feature a significant role for her. She brings in something that has been lacking: conflict with the crew.

Nothing was ever made of the Maquis background of half the crew, so we have spent three seasons with a group that all share the same core values and all basically get along. Seven comes from a very different background, has a very different set of values, and is not even particularly interested in getting along. Her very presence creates conflict. As a Borg, she was a threat to the ship, and the rest of the crew are wary of her. She brings in enormous scientific expertise, but expects her opinions to be accepted as a matter of course, which brings her into conflict with Torres, Janeway, and others.

Particularly interesting is the relationship that evolves between Seven and Janeway, who sometimes seems like a mentor to her, at other times an obstacle or even an adversary. When Seven denounces Janeway for trying to stifle her individuality, she sounds like a rebellious teen daughter - and the pain and disappointment on Janeway's face seems very much like that of a mother. The season finale reinforces that these two strong women have very different values, that Seven is never going to simply conform to Janeway's views. This is also good: They need to accept each other as they are, and find a working relationship despite their differences.


DEPARTURES AND LOITERERS: KES, HARRY KIM, AND THE REST
The other "big thing" that happens in Season Four is the departure of Kes... Something that really shouldn't have happened. Sure, it makes perfect sense that one of the supporting regulars would be let go to make room for Seven. But it makes no sense for it to have been Kes, a character whose role (as the Doctor's assistant and his humanizing influence) has not been replaced by Seven in any way, and a character whose final Season Three spotlight episode doubled as a statement of intent regarding future direction for her.

It's evident that the original plan was to let go of Harry Kim, a character so useless that writers have acknowledged deliberately avoiding giving him large roles in their scripts. Then actor Garrett Wang made a People Magazine list, which for whatever reason was seen as making him untouchable. I don't think it was a particularly good decision - Something made even more visible by how little Harry does over the course of Season Four, with a good showing in The Killing Game being the only time the entire year in which he doesn't seem like a spare part - one whose only real job (spouting Technobabble) has been made redundant by Seven.

Harry isn't the only character turned into a glorified extra by Seven's introduction. By mid-season, she has been set up in her own area of the ship - Astrometrics - and is now given the tasks that in previous seasons would have fallen under B'Elanna's purview. While Roxann Dawson's pregnancy certainly limited her participation in the mid-season, it does feel very much as if her previously prominent role has been pushed far to the back to make more room for Seven. What can be said of a season in which Neelix gets more memorable character material than B'Elanna Torres?


A CHANGE OF ALTITUDE: HINTS OF PROGRESS
But as I said at the top of this overview, I come largely to praise Season Four, which feels more alive and far less stagnant than Seasons Two and Three often did. Despite the overuse of Seven, a large part of the credit does belong to her, and to the way she shakes up the overly-comfortable cast dynamic. But there are other ways in which this season moves the series forward.

For the first three seasons, the relationship of Voyager to Starfleet is constant. Starfleet believes the ship is destroyed, and there is no way for our regulars to contact home and their families to let them know otherwise. Every so often, there would be a chance for the ship to possibly get home or possibly send a message... But this would always end in defeat so that the status-quo would be unchanged.

Message in a Bottle, right around the middle of this season, finally changes that. The discovery of the Hirogen communications relay allows the ship to contact home, and to receive messages. They now know about the Dominion War and the destruction of the Maquis, and their families now know they are alive. The problem is now being worked from two ends, with Starfleet certainly devoting at least some energy to shortening Voyager's journey.

That same episode kicks off an arc of episodes centering around the Hirogen, a predator species that at first seems a little too much like... well, Predator. Early episodes present the Hirogen as so one-dimensional, one could be forgiven for thinking the Kazon had been simply given a new design. Then Prey successfully makes them feel formidable, with Voyager clearly on the losing end of a confrontation with them. The Killing Game lends them even more dimension, as all the arguments viewers might have about how a species like this couldn't sustain itself are actually made part and parcel of the plot.

Though I suspect that two-parter will receive some follow up at some point, it does work as a resolution of the arc, which is an overall highly successful run of episodes. One hopes the series will continue to do occasional arcs of linked episodes in the future.


SEASON FIVE WISHLIST
The changes made to the status quo are a good thing - But instead of simply letting this sit as the "new normal," the show needs to build on these changes. I'd like to see occasional bursts of communication with Starfleet, perhaps seeking intelligence that might help with the Dominion War. Also, as the season finale reminds us, Janeway's actions in Scorpion have actually helped the Borg to expand and grow more powerful. It would be interested to see her forced to deal with the fallout of that - and I don't just mean in the form of some random alien out for revenge.

I also hope the hints at the end of Hope and Fear, of Janeway and Seven accepting that they have different values and working together despite that, are followed through. There's more dramatic potential in Seven working with the crew but holding a different value system than there is in simply transforming her into another Proper Starfleet Officer (ironic that the former member of the Collective has more individuality than most of the rest of the crew).

And while I do think the addition of Seven has been a benefit to the show, and I definitely would like her to remain prominent... It might be OK for there to be just a little less of her, so that she's not succeeding at the expense of the rest of the cast. For all of its problems, Voyager has a genuinely pretty strong ensemble. Pare back on "The Seven of Nine Show," please, and start remembering the rest of the cast for more than one or two episodes at a time.


IN SUMMATION

I have come to accept that Voyager will never be the show I wish it was - the show that can occasionally be glimpsed in jewels like The Thaw, Scorpion, and Living Witness. Save for the occasional story, the series is determined to play it safe inside its action/adventure bubble.

Season Four doesn't change this, but it does manage to push the edges of that bubble, making Voyager much better as the show that it is. I'm still not wildly enthusiastic about it as a series - But for the first time since Season One, I'm looking back on a year of Voyager with a lot more good feelings than bad.

Here's hoping it can further improve on that next season!


Previous: Season Three
Next: Season Five

Review Index

To receive new review updates, follow me:

On Twitter:

On Threads:

Sunday, January 4, 2015

4-18, 4-19. The Killing Game.

Janeway as a cafe owner in Nazi-occupied France.
THE PLOT:

The Hirogen have taken control of Voyager. The Hirogen Alpha, Karr (Danny Goldring), is intrigued by the possibilities of the ship's holodeck, has outfitted most of his Starfleet prisoners with neural interfaces, replacing their identities with those of characters within their holodeck programs.  Effectively, the [I]Voyager[/I] crew become different people, within deadly simulations of historical battles, with Karr studying their behavior as the situations unfold.

Janeway has been made into the owner of a cafe in the Nazi occupied French village Sainte Claire. Tuvok is her bartender, Seven a singer. They are all members of the French Resistance, secretly paving the way for American forces to liberate the village. But the Hirogen Beta, Turanj (Mark Deakins), has become impatient with his commander's game. He wants to begin the proper hunt - stalking the members of the Voyager crew and killing them all!


CHARACTERS:

Capt. Janeway: One of the pleasures of this two-parter is seeing the regulars in different roles, yet still true to their natures. Even stripped of her identity, Janeway is completely in charge. Her interactions with Tuvok and Seven are instantly familiar, with Tuvok the trusted advisor and Seven the person she wants to trust despite strain and tension. The main difference between Janeway with the neural implant and without it is that, with her identity returned, she is able to deal with the larger threat of the Hirogen. I wish there had been more interaction between her and the Hirogen Alpha in Part Two, as I enjoyed the scenes in which the two commanders reasoned with each other, two intelligent officers finding common ground in the midst of chaos.

Seven of Nine: Is the first crew member to regain her identity, thanks to her Borg plot devices, and gets the most prominent supporting role. Again. I'd complain if I actually thought any of the other regulars would be preferable, but Seven's strained interactions with Janeway inject an extra layer of tension into the first part. Within the simulation, Janeway's Resistance leader worries that Seven may be a traitor and is prepared to kill her. This leaves Seven working to return Janeway's identity to her, even as the woman she's trying to save is pulling her gun to shoot her as a traitor. Part Two gives her much less to do, allowing some strong moments for the rest of the cast, though she still gets a memorable bit in which she stands up to Turanj, showing no fear at his threat of execution.

The Doctor: Is forced to collaborate with the Hirogen Alpha. He really has no choice. With the crew thrust into violent holographic simulations with the safeties turned off, the Doctor's options are to patch up the crew so that they can continue to "play the game," or to refuse and watch his shipmates die horribly. He does remain alert for an opportunity to do more, however; and when Seven is brought to him with severe injuries, he is able to neutralize her neural implant so that she can get the rest to start fighting back.

Harry Kim: Gets his best episode of the season - probably his best episode since The Chute. He shows both cleverness and grit in his interactions with the Hirogen, aiding first the Doctor and then Janeway while convincing his captors that he is doing their bidding. Garrett Wang rises to some decent material with a genuinely strong performance. Plus, it's the only episode thus far this season in which Harry couldn't have been seamlessly replaced by a paperclip.

Hirogen: "Species that don't change die! ...We've allowed our predatory instincts to dominate us... We've spread ourselves too thin. We're no longer a culture, we have no identity. In another thousand years, no one will remember the name Hirogen!" Karr recognizes that the inability to think beyond the immediate hunt is leading his species on a slow path to extinction. His motives for subjecting the Voyager crew to a series of holographic horrors lend him a shade of gray that has been absent from previous Hirogen. At the same time, we see that the Hirogen are not just aggressors - They are also victims of their own, inflexible ideology. Appropriately, in Part Two, Turanj is talked back to the traditional Hirogen path by a holographic simulation of a Nazi in the dying days of World War II - one failed ideologue inspiring another to self-destructive aggression.


THOUGHTS:

The Killing Game is written by Brannon Braga and Joe Menosky, who partnered for the superb season-bridging Scorpion. This two-parter is not of that quality, nor is it trying to be. This is a large-form example of a tendency both writers share: Playing games with the show's "reality," putting the characters into bizarre situations to see what might happen. This can result in a terrible episode (Braga's Genesis springs to mind, as does Menosky's Masks) - but when these writers are on form, the results can also be a lot of fun.

Happily, I found The Killing Game to be tremendously entertaining... albeit, only for about 70% of its running time. Like a lot of two-parters, there isn't quite enough to really fill two episodes, and the last half of Part Two starts to feel more than a little stretched out. Notably, there are at least two too many cutaways to another holodeck, in which Neelix and the Doctor have "comedy" dealings with some holographic Klingons.

But for at least an episode and a half, it is very entertaining. I particularly enjoyed seeing how the regulars' personalities kept showing through, even without their memories. It might have been more off-the-wall fun to have had them in very different roles - But it feels more "right" to see the characters paralleling their familiar roles even when given different identities and memories.

The use of the Hirogen is clever, too, developing them beyond their previous "Predator meets Star Trek" status. I find myself hoping that the events of this episode are followed up in the next Hirogen episode, and genuinely intrigued to see where they might be taken from here.


Overall Rating: 7/10.

Previous Episode: Retrospect
Next Episode: Vis a Vis 


Search Amazon.com for Star Trek: Voyager

Review Index

To receive new review updates, follow me:

On Twitter:

On Threads:

Sunday, November 9, 2014

4-16. Prey.

Hirogen hunters pursue their prey.

THE PLOT:

Voyager encounters a Hirogen ship adrift in space. Only the Hirogen Alpha (Tony Todd) remains alive, the other hunter having been decapitated by their prey: A member of Species 8472!

When the starship stops for the Hirogen, its prey takes the opportunity to come aboard, and immediately begins sabotaging life support and gravity on a section of the ship. In such close proximity to his prey, the Alpha demands to be allowed to continue his hunt. Janeway reluctantly agrees - but she insists they make every effort to capture the creature rather than kill it, dismissing the objections of Seven of Nine.

They find Species 8472 quickly enough. But when it uses its telepathic abilities to plea for a safe return to its own dimension, Janeway grants the request and denies the Hirogen its kill. With more Hirogen ships closing fast, however, her moral stand may well result in the destruction of the starship Voyager!


CHARACTERS:

Capt. Janeway: Views the damaged Hirogen ship as an opportunity to improve relations by showing compassion. Which doesn't stop her from being practical enough to also gather some key information about this new alien threat. Scientific curiosity probably drives her initial desire to use non-lethal force against Species 8472. But the creature's plea to return home, its evident desire to avoid further conflict, earns Janeway's sympathy. She is making a genuine moral stand when she protects the creature, and is clearly willing to see it through even when her ship comes under bombardment from other Hirogen vessels.

Seven of Nine: Abhors Species 8472, remembering all too clearly the devastation visited on the Borg: "They destroyed millions of drones, hundreds of our worlds. I have reason to be 'agitated,'" she tells Tuvok. But that's only part of what brings her into conflict with Janeway. She has a very different viewpoint than the captain. The evolving situation is filtered through a tactical viewpoint for Seven, rather than a moral one. She argues against stopping to help the Hirogen, and actually recommends firing on the damaged ship - Kill the enemy while he is weakened. Later, she acknowledges that Janeway's decision was justified... Not because of any likely futile hope of improving relations, but because valuable information was gained. When Janeway orders Seven to assist in returning Species 8472 home, Seven balks, prompting some excellent Janeway/Seven scenes that may redefine their entire relationship.

Tuvok: Tim Russ has come to truly inhabit Tuvok. While this isn't a huge episode for the Vulcan, he gets some very good side moments. I particularly enjoyed his impassive response when his area of the ship loses gravity while he's in mid-sentence. He simply reaches for a handhold and keeps talking, with just a flicker of expression that makes the moment extremely funny. In service to the plot, Tuvok's telepathic abilities allow the wounded Species 8472 alien to communicate, prompting the third act crisis.

Hirogen: Prey offers a much better showing for the Hirogen than Hunters did. They still come across as two-dimensional, driven entirely by the desire to hunt; my reference to the Predator films in the last review seems all too apt. But unlike the blatantly stupid Hirogen who essentially defeated themselves, this episode gives us a genuinely formidable and cunning antagonist in Tony Todd's Alpha. Todd is terrific, seizing on the moments in which we see the Alpha's keen observational skills. He recognizes Seven's abhorrence of Species 8472, and seizes on that to manipulate her. More of this kind of cunning could make this new adversary into a real threat.


THOUGHTS:

"This prey is resilient."
-A Hirogen hunter pays a rare compliment.

Prey opens with one of the best teasers Star Trek: Voyager has offered, a precredit scene that sets the tone, grips the viewer, and remakes the Hirogen as a credible threat all in a few short minutes. This opening is from the point of view of the Alpha, as he and his Beta (Clint Carmichael) track down their prey. The Beta wants to destroy it from a safe distance, lest they "lose the moment." The Alpha wants to experience the glory of finishing this challenging hunt firsthand. They track their prey to an asteroid, where they execute what the Alpha observes is "a flawless kill."

The entire sequence is stunning - Superbly paced and executed by director Allan Eastman, well-acted, genuinely tense. The reveal that the prey is a member of Species 8472 is the perfect bow to slip around this already wonderfully-wrapped package.

The rest of the episode is good, too. Between writer Brannon Braga's script (one of his best) and Eastman's atmospheric direction, the pace remains fast and the tension high thoughout. The exploration of the Hirogen ship reveals the remains of past prey, in a sequence that's genuinely creepy even before Tom Paris stumbles across the Beta's severed head. The interactions between Janeway and the Alpha, and later between Seven and Janeway, are charged with conflict. Janeway and the Alpha create an alliance, but their values are so opposed that each seems to know that they are destined to end up as enemies again. Seven and Janeway are well-established allies, but Seven is so sharply in disagreement with Janeway's decisions that a rift is inevitable. I don't usually think of Braga as a character writer, but he brings levels to the Janeway/Seven relationship that have not been apparent in most previous episodes but which fit their characters completely.


JANEWAY VS. SEVEN:

What makes the Janeway/Seven interactions so strong is that each has a good point. Janeway is the captain, and as such does get to make the final decision. Once her decision is made, it is inappropriate to continue arguing. In this, Seven is guilty of gross breaches of protocol long before Janeway calls her on the carpet. Seven, however, is quite right that Janeway's actions put Voyager at risk. The way the climax plays out, the ship is likely minutes from destruction if Janeway stays her course. Seven argues that she saves the ship by violating orders, and what we see lends real merit to that argument. However, she does violate orders - orders that are entirely consistent with Starfleet protocol. Janeway doesn't show any sign of incompetence or instability, leaving Seven making decisions that are rightly Janeway's. By any reasonable standard, Janeway's final punishment of the former Borg is actually ridiculously lenient.

The final scene of the episode is a great one, as we see Janeway and Seven left as completely alien from each other as Janeway and the Alpha had been. Janeway is clearly hurting at punishing Seven, whom she has protected and nurtured throughout this season. It tortures her that she cannot make Seven even comprehend her point of view. Seven, who has reacted to Janeway as a maternal figure in the past, worrying about winning her approval, now reacts as a rebellious teen might at being grounded. This extends to her final statement, which could easily come from the mouth of a teen daughter during a fight with her mother:

"I believe that you are punishing me because I do not think the way you do, because I am not becoming more like you. You claim to respect my individuality - but in fact, you are frightened by it."

All of this is good material, which should bring even more new levels to the Janeway/Seven interactions in the future - That is, if the series can resist its tendency to reset everything by the next episode.

Overall Rating: 9/10.

Previous Episode; Hunters
Next Episode: Retrospect 


Search Amazon.com for Star Trek: Voyager

Review Index

To receive new review updates, follow me:

On Twitter:

On Threads:

Tuesday, October 21, 2014

4-15. Hunters.

Seven meets a Hirogen Alpha (Tiny Ron)
THE PLOT

Voyager receives a garbled message from Starfleet Command, sent using the same alien relay network the crew used to contact them. The bulk of the message was caught in a relay station not far from the ship, so Janeway sets course to retrieve the rest.

As they near the station, Seven of Nine is able to extract more of the transmission. Most of it consists of letters from home. As the messages are delivered, the crew reacts in various ways: Some joyous at contact from loved ones long unseen; some anxious as no letter makes it to them; others horrified as they learn of the devastation caused by the war back home.

Meanwhile, the Hirogen, the alien race who lays claim to the relay network, intercepts the transmission. An Alpha Hirogen (Tiny Ron) moves to intercept Voyager, determined to claim the first kill for himself - and he arrives just in time to capture Seven and Tuvok!


CHARACTERS

Capt. Janeway: Receives a letter from Mark, her fiance... But this long-nurtured dream turns into a nightmare as she realizes that what she's received is a "Dear John" letter. Kate Mulgrew is fantastic in the scene in which Janeway reads the letter, and writer Jeri Taylor wisely refrains from having her read aloud or any similar hamfisted tactic. The camera simply stays on her face, allowing us to see her expression collapse into numb shock as she reads the words in front of her. It's probably a relief to get to play hardball with the Hirogen not much later, and the alien hunters pick a particularly bad day to get on her bad side.

Seven: Clearly regards Janeway as a mentor, even a friend, and her actions throughout the episode show just how important her opinion is to her. She misses needed sleep to retrieve more of the message as they travel to the relay station, responding to the Doctor's irritation at her by stating that "this message is important to the captain." When the transmission is interrupted by unstable Technobabble that can somehow be stabilized by piloting a shuttle closer to the station, Janeway insists Tuvok accompany her. Seven fears this may be due to mistrust, and is visibly relieved when Tuvok tells her that it is Starfleet protocol to send at least two people on an Away Mission.

Tuvok: When Neelix delivers his letter, he insists that he will finish his duties before reading it. "Do you have any reason to believe the contents of the message will change?" he says when Neelix protests. However, once the Talaxian is out of the room, he quickly sets aside his report to read his news from home. He does want that contact from his family - He just wants it to be private, something I can relate to quite well.

Tom: As the crew becomes excited, he tries to pretend that he doesn't care about word from home. "What I have on Voyager is so much better than anything I ever had back there," he tells Torres. He advises an anxious Harry to stop hoping for a letter in order to avoid disappointment... But when he learns that he has received a message from his father, it's clear he cannot follow his own advice. He resists reading his message, too afraid that what will be said will disappoint him all over again. He again shows his genuine feelings for B'Elanna, however, dropping his self-pity the instant she reveals how horrible her own news from home was - That most of her friends in the Maquis are dead at the hands of the Dominion.

Harry: When he doesn't immediately receive a letter, he begins to worry that he's not going to get one - perhaps fearing that he's so irrelevant, that even his own family doesn't miss him. Don't worry, Harry: As Circe Lannister once observed, parents have little choice but to love their children. Still, I suppose if you can admit that you're Harry Kim, then acknowledging the problem may be the first step toward recovery.

Hirogen: With two appearances in as many episodes, it's clear that the Hirogen are being set up as a new recurring menace to the crew. Unfortunately, there is little so far that's encouraging. They are driven by a desire to hunt prey, and they crave challenging prey... Which makes them basically the Predator if it was able to speak. Come to think of it, having them be so chatty may be a mistake, since it completely drains any sense of threat, particularly when they behave as relentlessly stupidly as they do in this episode. Janeway defeats the Hirogen here by... Well, by letting them literally kill themselves by shooting at the only thing keeping their ships from being sucked into a black hole. I'd call them the Kazon with better makeup, only I don't think the Kazon ever did anything quite as purely idiotic as that.


THOUGHTS

I have to give Voyager points here. Message in a Bottle introduced a new situation, with Starfleet now aware that Voyager had survived and was in the Delta Quadrant. It was a situation that genuinely demanded follow up... But I did not expect it to come in the very next episode.

Hunters builds its entire narrative around the elements introduced in the previous episode: contact with Starfleet; the alien relay network; the belligerent Hirogen. All three elements are used, and used in a way that keeps Hunters as a unified episode. More than that - Jeri Taylor's script helps resolve my chief complaint about Message in a Bottle, showing the sense of significance to the crew that was previously missing.  In short, this episode makes its predecessor a better episode by its presence.

Though the Hirogen end up being unimpressive in their first proper outing, the focus here is really on the characters - And the character material works well, because it convinces. Chakotay and B'Elanna learn of the destruction of the Maquis, and B'Elanna reacts first by wanting to take a revenge that would be impossible even if she wasn't ridiculously far from home, then by focusing on giving good news to Tom and Harry. Jokes about Harry aside, the reactions of both him and Tom feel right for their characters, and Tuvok's desire to read his news privately feels absolutely correct for him. There's even a nice interaction between Janeway and Seven, when Janeway reminds her that she likely has family back home that she hasn't met yet, making all this more relevant for the former Borg than she wants to believe.

Thanks to the strong character focus, this episode ends up being a good one.  If the Hirogen felt like more of a true threat, it would be among the season's better offerings - but even as it stands, I found this episode very enjoyable.


Overall Rating: 7/10.

Previous Episode: Message in a Bottle
Next Episode: Prey


Search Amazon.com for Star Trek: Voyager

Review Index

To receive new review updates, follow me:

On Twitter:

On Threads:

Monday, October 13, 2014

4-14. Message in a Bottle.

The Doctor prepares to make contact
with the Alpha Quadrant!
THE PLOT

Seven of Nine's work in the astrometrics lab yields an exciting result: a chance at contact with a Starfleet vessel! She has tapped into an alien relay network, property of a race known as the Hirogen, whose reach extends to the edge of the Alpha Quadrant, and believes that she can use that relay to get a message through to the Starfleet vessel. When the message proves too weak to get through, a desperate Janeway authorizes stronger methods: Transmitting the Doctor through the network to directly communicate!

The transmission is a success, and the Doctor finds himself on the USS Prometheus. But all is not well. This ship is a prototype, designed for use in deep space tactical missions against the Dominion ("The who?" the Doctor wonders). Given its advanced capabilities, it has become a target - boarded by the Romulans, who have killed the entire Starfleet crew and intend to take the ship back to Romulan space.

Now the Doctor must find a way to retake the ship, both so that he can complete his mission to deliver word of Voyager's situation to Starfleet and so that he can rejoin his own crew. He has only one ally: The Prometheus' Emergency Medical Hologram (Andy Dick) - but this EMH is as experimental as the ship he serves on, and his behavior is erratic and often cowardly!


CHARACTERS

Capt. Janeway: Knows that she and the crew should not get their hopes up too much. As she observes, the crew has been through this before. Even so, she admits to Chakotay that she couldn't help herself from dusting off her letters to her loved ones and bringing them up-to-date. When the Doctor returns, having successfully made contact with Starfleet, she is moved to declare that the enormous distance between them and home seems less vast now that contact has been made.

Doctor: Robert Picardo takes the lead, and is splendid as usual. Paired with the supposedly more advanced Emergency Medical Hologram Mark 2, the Doctor moves from jealousy at his model being superseded to exasperation at the younger hologram's cowardice. He acts as the voice of experience, from pushing the Mark 2 to move beyond the boundaries of his program to irritably guiding the hologram through something as simple as crawling into a Jeffries tube. The interplay between Picardo and Dick is very funny, and greatly elevates this episode.

Torres/Seven: The episode's "B" plot sees Torres annoyed about Seven's rudeness, until she finally confronts Seven about it. This is very expendable material, which covers a lot of the same ground that seemed already dealt with in Scientific Method, when Torres gave her speech to Seven about how if she could learn to become a Starfleet officer, then she was sure Seven could as well. Still, it's well-performed by the two actresses, and gets a nice payoff when Torres voices her approval of Seven's "diplomacy" at the end.

Tom/Harry: The episode also dredges up a "C" plot, presumably to fill air time, with Tom and Harry attempting to create a new medical hologram. Which feels thin to begin with, given that the Doctor is only away for a matter of hours when Tom becomes desperate enough to propose it. I'd say this was meant to be comedy relief, but since the main plot is played so lightly in any case, it feels unnecessary... and, unlike the Robert Picardo/Andy Dick interplay in the "A" plot, it's also unfunny. Much better had those 5 - 6 minutes gone to, say, actually showing the Doctor making contact with someone from Starfleet instead of just telling Janeway about it afterward.


THOUGHTS

I'm torn in reviewing Message in a Bottle. On its own merits, it is an entertaining episode, certainly one of the better installments penned by the erratic Lisa Klink. It moves at a snappy pace and has plenty of humor, much of which works. Its pace lags a bit every time we (needlessly) cut back to Voyager, and the Tom/Harry scenes feel like desperate padding, but the "A" plot is consistently enjoyable.  As a light adventure story, it is quite decent.

My problem is that this should be a significant episode: Voyager finally makes contact with the Alpha Quadrant, and the crew members' families and Starfleet finally know that they are alive. It's the first real progress the crew has made in contacting home. It's a big moment... Yet it comes in an episode that plays out as a standard runaround, with the significant events occurring entirely offscreen.

I'd have much preferred a straight drama rather than a light adventure. Drop the Romulans, and have the Doctor make contact with the crew and be taken to some Starfleet admirals and bureaucrats and scientists (maybe Dr. Zimmerman himself?) for debriefing and for study as to how he has so altered from his programming. Tension could come from whether or not he will be allowed to return to Voyager; or whether he might be deactivated, his holo-emitter taken away for study and potential use in the Dominion War. At the end, the Doctor's message, and the reply he brings back, could occur onscreen, in an episode actually focused on that - rather than the message being grafted onto a typical "ship held hostage" episode.

But that's me creating a bit of mental fanfiction out of what I'd have liked this episode to have been... Which is to say, an episode along the lines of a good Deep Space 9. Taken as another light adventure episode, much along the same lines as Waking Moments or Displaced, I'll acknowledge that what is there is reasonably good and often a lot of fun to watch. I was entertained (well, except for the Tom/Harry scenes), and Robert Picardo is terrific as always.

In short: Taken as what it is, Message in a Bottle works pretty well, and that's what my overall score reflects. I just wish this particular script had gone in a different direction and had tried to do more.


Overall Rating: 6/10.

Previous Episode: Waking Moments
Next Episode: Hunters


Search Amazon.com for Star Trek: Voyager

Review Index

To receive new review updates, follow me:

On Twitter:

On Threads: