Showing posts with label Romulans. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Romulans. Show all posts

Monday, October 13, 2014

4-14. Message in a Bottle.

The Doctor prepares to make contact
with the Alpha Quadrant!
THE PLOT

Seven of Nine's work in the astrometrics lab yields an exciting result: a chance at contact with a Starfleet vessel! She has tapped into an alien relay network, property of a race known as the Hirogen, whose reach extends to the edge of the Alpha Quadrant, and believes that she can use that relay to get a message through to the Starfleet vessel. When the message proves too weak to get through, a desperate Janeway authorizes stronger methods: Transmitting the Doctor through the network to directly communicate!

The transmission is a success, and the Doctor finds himself on the USS Prometheus. But all is not well. This ship is a prototype, designed for use in deep space tactical missions against the Dominion ("The who?" the Doctor wonders). Given its advanced capabilities, it has become a target - boarded by the Romulans, who have killed the entire Starfleet crew and intend to take the ship back to Romulan space.

Now the Doctor must find a way to retake the ship, both so that he can complete his mission to deliver word of Voyager's situation to Starfleet and so that he can rejoin his own crew. He has only one ally: The Prometheus' Emergency Medical Hologram (Andy Dick) - but this EMH is as experimental as the ship he serves on, and his behavior is erratic and often cowardly!


CHARACTERS

Capt. Janeway: Knows that she and the crew should not get their hopes up too much. As she observes, the crew has been through this before. Even so, she admits to Chakotay that she couldn't help herself from dusting off her letters to her loved ones and bringing them up-to-date. When the Doctor returns, having successfully made contact with Starfleet, she is moved to declare that the enormous distance between them and home seems less vast now that contact has been made.

Doctor: Robert Picardo takes the lead, and is splendid as usual. Paired with the supposedly more advanced Emergency Medical Hologram Mark 2, the Doctor moves from jealousy at his model being superseded to exasperation at the younger hologram's cowardice. He acts as the voice of experience, from pushing the Mark 2 to move beyond the boundaries of his program to irritably guiding the hologram through something as simple as crawling into a Jeffries tube. The interplay between Picardo and Dick is very funny, and greatly elevates this episode.

Torres/Seven: The episode's "B" plot sees Torres annoyed about Seven's rudeness, until she finally confronts Seven about it. This is very expendable material, which covers a lot of the same ground that seemed already dealt with in Scientific Method, when Torres gave her speech to Seven about how if she could learn to become a Starfleet officer, then she was sure Seven could as well. Still, it's well-performed by the two actresses, and gets a nice payoff when Torres voices her approval of Seven's "diplomacy" at the end.

Tom/Harry: The episode also dredges up a "C" plot, presumably to fill air time, with Tom and Harry attempting to create a new medical hologram. Which feels thin to begin with, given that the Doctor is only away for a matter of hours when Tom becomes desperate enough to propose it. I'd say this was meant to be comedy relief, but since the main plot is played so lightly in any case, it feels unnecessary... and, unlike the Robert Picardo/Andy Dick interplay in the "A" plot, it's also unfunny. Much better had those 5 - 6 minutes gone to, say, actually showing the Doctor making contact with someone from Starfleet instead of just telling Janeway about it afterward.


THOUGHTS

I'm torn in reviewing Message in a Bottle. On its own merits, it is an entertaining episode, certainly one of the better installments penned by the erratic Lisa Klink. It moves at a snappy pace and has plenty of humor, much of which works. Its pace lags a bit every time we (needlessly) cut back to Voyager, and the Tom/Harry scenes feel like desperate padding, but the "A" plot is consistently enjoyable.  As a light adventure story, it is quite decent.

My problem is that this should be a significant episode: Voyager finally makes contact with the Alpha Quadrant, and the crew members' families and Starfleet finally know that they are alive. It's the first real progress the crew has made in contacting home. It's a big moment... Yet it comes in an episode that plays out as a standard runaround, with the significant events occurring entirely offscreen.

I'd have much preferred a straight drama rather than a light adventure. Drop the Romulans, and have the Doctor make contact with the crew and be taken to some Starfleet admirals and bureaucrats and scientists (maybe Dr. Zimmerman himself?) for debriefing and for study as to how he has so altered from his programming. Tension could come from whether or not he will be allowed to return to Voyager; or whether he might be deactivated, his holo-emitter taken away for study and potential use in the Dominion War. At the end, the Doctor's message, and the reply he brings back, could occur onscreen, in an episode actually focused on that - rather than the message being grafted onto a typical "ship held hostage" episode.

But that's me creating a bit of mental fanfiction out of what I'd have liked this episode to have been... Which is to say, an episode along the lines of a good Deep Space 9. Taken as another light adventure episode, much along the same lines as Waking Moments or Displaced, I'll acknowledge that what is there is reasonably good and often a lot of fun to watch. I was entertained (well, except for the Tom/Harry scenes), and Robert Picardo is terrific as always.

In short: Taken as what it is, Message in a Bottle works pretty well, and that's what my overall score reflects. I just wish this particular script had gone in a different direction and had tried to do more.


Overall Rating: 6/10.

Previous Episode: Waking Moments
Next Episode: Hunters


Search Amazon.com for Star Trek: Voyager

Review Index

To receive new review updates, follow me:

On Twitter:

On Threads:

Tuesday, May 31, 2011

1-07. Eye of the Needle.


THE PLOT

When Harry detects a possible wormhole, Voyager deviates from its course to investigate. They do find a wormhole - but it's in a state of collapse, and is already practically microscopic. Despite this, they are able to send a proble through... and that probe is quickly scanned by somebody on the other side!

Harry and Torres manage to establish voice communication. But when Janeway tells the captain on the other side of the wormhole where they are, he refuses to believe them. He insists they are "Federation spies" - leading to the discovery that their would-be savior is a Romulan, deeply suspicious of Starfleet. Janeway persists in trying to maintain contact, however, determined to win the man's trust so that they can at least send messages back home. Then Torres makes another discovery - a chance that they might be able to use the signal from the probe to stabilize transport. If it works, there is a chance they could beam back home!


CHARACTERS

Capt. Janeway: Seeing Harry's excitement over the wormhole, she wants to support him in making something of his discovery. When their investigation of the wormhole leads to communication with the Alpha Quadrant, however, her pursuit of further communication becomes much more intense. I'm reminded of her near-desperate promise to Tuvok to get him back home. Some of that same desperation comes into her voice and gestures as she tries to talk to the Romulan captain, willing him to believe her seemingly impossible story.

I've criticized Janeway several times in these reviews, so let me make clear that this criticism does not extend to Kate Mulgrew, whose performance has been reliable and, in this episode, is excellent. She also does her job as captain by setting aside her prejudices about the holographic doctor when Kes expresses concern about his treatment to her. She promises Kes to look into the matter and, to her credit, follows through on that. On the whole, a rather good episode for her, the first one in which she actually starts to feel like a real character rather than a cardboard construct labelled, "Captain."

Doctor: Is only gradually coming to think of himself as anything other than the Emergency Medical Hologram. He brushes off the rudeness of crew members toward him, and seems to have no reaction at all to the thought that Janeway might reprogram him. When Janeway presses him for how she can meet his needs, he does show some emotion, mainly courtesy of Robert Picardo's excellent nonverbal reactions as the doctor doesn't quite meet Janeway's gaze from that moment. There's a lovely fumbling in his voice as he responds to Janeway's proposal to give control of his activation and deactivation strictly to him, so that he can switch himself off when there's nothing to do and avoid being switched off in mid-task.

Kes: Continuing her work with the doctor, she is proving to be a quick study. She enjoys studying first aid and anatomy, and expresses an interest in attending medical school upon the ship's return to the Federation. She is developing a distinct bond with the doctor, and it clearly bothers her when crew members insist on treating him "like a hypo spray." She makes a point of treating him with politeness and respect, and presses Janeway for better treatment of the doctor. The scenes between Jennifer Lien and Robert Picardo continue to be highlights of the series.

Torres: Tells Harry that the Maquis are as close to family as she has ever had, and that there is no one back home to care whether she is alive or dead. She shows compassion for Harry's earnestness over his wormhole, assuring him that their efforts "will work."


THOUGHTS

Eye of the Needle is not just a good episode. It's a key episode in Janeway's development. Prior to this installment, the only characters who have worked as characters have been Kes, the Doctor, and arguably Neelix (he's annoying as hell, but at least he has a distinct character). The rest of the cast have been 2-dimensional constructs. And despite a good effort by Kate Mulgrew, that has unfortunately extended to Janeway as well.

Until this episode, which does something vital for the health of the series: It makes Janweway into a genuine human being! Mulgrew obviously responds to the material, giving a performance that perfectly balances the emotion of the situation with the restraint required of a ship's captain. When the lead is something more than a cypher, it does very good things for the series as a whole. I just hope this episode is a sign of sustained improvement on that front.

The story works well, moving along at a nice pace and with the characters responding intelligently to each new discovery. There's a rising sense of hope among the characters throughout... which of course means that hope must be brutally dashed at the end, given that the series continues for another 6+ years. I do think the final plot turn, Tuvok's revelation at the very end, is just a bit much, but the other disappointments do create an effective payoff.

A good episode, one which washes away the disappointment of the previous one quite nicely.


Overall Rating: 8/10.


Search Amazon.com for Star Trek: Voyager




Review Index